The two numbers that matter
Contribution margin is the selling price minus the food cost of one portion. If a risotto sells for $22 and its ingredients cost $6, its contribution margin is $16. Use the price before sales tax or VAT.
Popularity is the item's share of sales within its category. Compare mains with mains and desserts with desserts, never across categories, because a guest who orders a main is choosing among mains.
The menu engineering formula
In the original method, an item counts as popular if its share of sales in its category is at least 70% of an equal share. With 10 mains, an equal share is 10%, so a main is popular if it accounts for 7% or more of main-course sales. The 70% line stops items from being labeled unpopular just for being slightly below average.
For margin, compare each item's contribution margin with the weighted average for its category: the total contribution margin of the category divided by the total number of items sold in it.
The menu engineering matrix: four quadrants
The labels sound blunt, but they make menu meetings faster, because each one comes with a clear default action.
- Stars: high popularity, high margin. Keep them visible, keep quality consistent and test small price rises.
- Plowhorses: high popularity, low margin. Raise the price a little, trim the portion cost or pair them with a high-margin side.
- Puzzles: low popularity, high margin. Move them to better spots, rename them, add a photo or have staff recommend them.
- Dogs: low popularity, low margin. Remove them, unless they serve a clear purpose, such as a children's dish or the vegetarian option a group needs.
A quick worked example
Say your dessert section sold 400 portions last month across five desserts. An equal share is 20%, so the popularity line is 14%, or 56 portions. The tiramisu sold 120 at a $7 margin. The lemon tart sold 40 at a $9 margin. The weighted average margin across all five desserts comes to $6.50.
The tiramisu is a star: popular and above the average margin. The lemon tart is a puzzle: it earns well but sits below the popularity line, so it needs better placement, a photo or a server's recommendation before you consider removing it.
Where layout comes in
The spreadsheet tells you what to change, and the layout is where much of the change happens. Puzzles in particular are often a visibility problem. Guests tend to notice the first and last items in a section, items with a photo and items set apart with a box or extra space.
Describe dishes in concrete terms, and avoid lining prices up in a neat column, which invites guests to scan for the cheapest. On a QR menu, the top of each section is the spot to give your stars and puzzles.
What a digital menu adds
Classic menu engineering only sees what was sold, and every change to a printed menu means a reprint. On a digital menu you can move a puzzle up its section, add a photo or rename it today, then compare its sales with the weeks before.
If orders rise, the problem was visibility. If they do not, look at what guests see on the item: the price, the description or the portion in the photo. On ArtOfMenu's Smart plan, sales reports show the before and after, and the menu order also adjusts itself to sales and to what guests look at.
Menu engineering and pricing
Repricing is one of the main actions the matrix suggests, especially for plowhorses. Make changes in small steps and watch whether popularity holds.
ArtOfMenu's Smart plan adds daily pricing: each evening it sets tomorrow's prices from the branch location, weather, special days and expected demand, inside the minimum and maximum you set per item. Menu engineering helps you choose those limits. A star can often carry a wider range, while a plowhorse that guests compare with other places may need a narrow one.
Common mistakes
Most menu engineering errors come from the data that goes into the matrix.
- Using last year's recipe costs after supplier prices have moved
- Comparing items across categories
- Analyzing a period with a holiday or closure that distorts sales
- Changing price, position and description at once, so you cannot tell what worked
- Removing a dog that a regular group orders every week without asking why
Updated: · The ArtOfMenu team





